iRubric: Compare/Contrast Writing: Holes Novel/Movie rubric

(draft) edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Compare/Contrast Writing: Holes Novel/Movie

Compare/Contrast Writing: Holes Book to Holes Movie

Students will compare/contrast the novel, Holes, with the movie, Holes.

Rubric Code: M752B2

By achriste

Draft

Public Rubric

Subject: English

Type: Writing

Grade Levels: 6-8


	6 100% = A Excellent! 12 pts	5 92% = A- Great! 11 pts	4 83% = B Good! 10 pts	3 75% = C Satisfactory 9 pts	2 67% = D+ Needs work 8 pts	1 58% = F Needs work 7 pts
Introduction/Summary 12 pts	6 Demonstrates a thorough understanding by skillfully summarizing the story in the introduction. Includes all 3 parts of the story.	5 Demonstrates a considerable understanding by summarizing the story in the introduction. Mentions all 3 parts of the story.	4 Demonstrates some understanding by summarizing the story in the introduction. Includes 2 of the 3 parts of the story.	3 Demonstrates some understanding by summarizing the story in the introduction. Includes 1 of the 3 parts of the story.	2 Demonstrates a limited understanding by vaguely summarizing the story in the introduction.	1 There is an introduction, but the summary is very limited or not included.
Similarities 12 pts	6 There are 3 fully explained similarities between the book and the movie.	5 There are 3 clear similarities between the book and the movie.	4 There are 2 clear similarities between the book and the movie. OR There are 3 similarities between the book and the movie, but one of them is not clear.	3 There is 1 clear similarity between the book and the movie. OR There are 3 similarities between the book and the movie, but more than one of them are not clear.	2 There are 3 similarities between the book and the movie, but none of them are clear.	1 There are less than 3 similarities between the book and the movie, and none of them are clear.
Differences 12 pts	6 There are 3 fully explained differences between the book and the movie.	5 There are 3 clear differences between the book and the movie.	4 There are 2 clear differences between the book and the movie. OR There are 3 differences between the book and the movie, but one of them is not clear.	3 There is 1 clear difference between the book and the movie. OR There are 3 differences between the book and the movie, but more than one of them are not clear.	2 There are 3 differences between the book and the movie, but none of them are clear.	1 There are less than 3 differences between the book and the movie, and none of them are clear.
Conclusion/Preference 12 pts	6 Clearly states at least 3 detailed reasons to justify preference of book or movie in the conclusion.	5 Includes at least 3 reasons to justify preference of book or movie in the conclusion.	4 Includes at least 2 detailed reasons to justify preference of book or movie in the conclusion.	3 Includes at least 1 detailed reason to justify preference of book or movie in the conclusion. OR Includes at least 2 reasons to justify preference of book or movie in the conclusion.	2 Includes at least 1 reason to justify preference of book or movie in the conclusion.	1 Student has included a preference of book or movie, however, no reasons are included to justify why.
Conventions 12 pts	6 Limited errors in grammar and/or spelling enhance the content.	5 Errors in grammar and/or spelling do not distract the reader from the content.	4 Errors in grammar and/or spelling slightly distract the reader from the content.	3 Errors in grammar and/or spelling distract the reader from the content.	2 Errors in grammar and/or spelling significantly distract the reader from the content.	1 Errors in grammar and/or spelling make the content difficult to understand.

Subjects:

Types:

Discuss this rubric