iRubric: Good-Better-Best (GBB) Feedback rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Good-Better-Best (GBB) Feedback

This rubrics rates the quality of feedback given to communicators, based on the Good-Better-Best method developed by Alan E. Nelson, Ed.D.

Rubric Code: L7C472

By aenelson

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: Communication

Type: Presentation

Grade Levels: Undergraduate, Graduate

Presentation Rubric
	Fair 3 pts	Good 4 pts	Excellent 5 pts	Comments (N/A)
Good Typically what you liked 2nd best; a specific behavior/item noticed	Fair - Generic - Weak - Unclear	Good - Specific - Neutral - Questionable accuracy	Excellent - Very specific - Positive - Affirming - Accurate	Comments
Better This is the area of improvement from the vantage of you as an audience member; constructive analysis; feedback	Fair - "You should have..." - Negative - Critical - Past oriented - Condescending -Non-existent ("It all seemed good to me.")	Good - Lack of strong future orientation -Focus on the speaker vs. you as an audience member - Lack of specificity - Accuracy possible but not strong	Excellent - Future oriented - Specific - Disclaimer of your perspective as an audience member<BR> - Upbeat - Honoring - Accurate	Comments
Best In your mind the best element of the speech; feedback on what went well from your perspective; specific	Fair - Generic - Same as good - Inaccurate - Lack specificity - Reduced by "but" statement	Good - Accuracy probable but not focused - Strong but lacking clarity; needs some specificity - Could benefit from more enthusiasm	Excellent - Very upbeat - Accurate - Leaves speaker with sense of honor and reward - Clear	Comments
Presentation
Verbal response	Fair Sits and talks	Good Stands and faces speaker	Excellent Stands, faces speaker, and speaks articulately	Comments