- Username
- Password
forgot?

iRubric: Toulmin's Argument Assignment for AS1 rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Toulmin's Argument Assignment for AS1 Toulmin's Argument Assignment for AW1 Simple rubric for sophomore Japanese EFL beginning academic writers. Rubric Code: V234C2B By marcopojp Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: English Type: Writing Grade Levels: 6-8

Toulmin's Argument Assignment
	Poor 0 pts	Fair 3 pts	Good 5 pts	Excellent 10 pts
Claim	Poor The claim is undistinguishable or doesn't exist.	Fair The claim is not quite clear, and needs developing.	Good The claim is well written but needs some clarifying.	Excellent The claim is easily distinguishable and well written.
Evidence (Data)	Poor The reason is unclear or missing.	Fair The reason is not quite clear and needs developing.	Good The reason is clearly identifable, but could use some clarifying	Excellent The reason supports the claim.
Warrant (General rule or rules)	Poor The warrant doesn't connect your claims to your evidence or it isn't easily identifiable.	Fair The warrant is unclear, but there is something connecting your claims and grounds.	Good The warrant is clearly identifiable, but could use some clarifying.	Excellent The warrant is well written, easily identifiable, and connects the claims and grounds of your argument efficiently.
Research	Poor Sources are not creditable; APA style is not followed; evidence is not connected to student asertions	Fair Sources are mixed with some creditable, some errors with APA style, some connection errors	Good Mostly creditable sources' few errors in APA, most connections clear to sources	Excellent Creditable sources are used; APA style is correct; sources are connected to student text, supports assertions,
Composition/Grammar/Mechanics/Usage	Poor Unacceptable composition and grammar and usage. Some elements are missing: ___ claim ___ evidence ___ warrant ___ conclusion ___ reflection ___ bibliography	Fair Three or more errors in composition and/or grammar and mechanics. All elements are used but some of the rules not followed. ___ Rule # _____	Good Minor errors composition style; minor errors in grammar mechanics and usage	Excellent Uses correct composition style; no errors in grammar mechanics and usage