iRubric: Graphic Novel rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Graphic Novel

Students will create a graphic novel for a story. The graphic novel should demonstrate comprehension and include graphic novel components.

Rubric Code: TXAW92A

By Nhoover1981

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: English

Type: Project

Grade Levels: 9-12

Romeo and Juliet Graphic Novel
	Excellent 4 pts	Good 3 pts	Fair 2 pts	Poor 1 pts
Panels	Excellent 6 or more panels were used, and the story line progresses in a logical sequence.	Good 5 pages were used, but the reader is confused from one page or panel to the next.	Fair 4 panels were used, and the story line is not sequential	Poor 3 or less panels used, little to no evidence of understanding of the play
Comprehension	Excellent Displays an extensive understanding of the characters, plot and setting. Enhances meaning of the play for the reader.	Good Displays a clear understanding of the characters, plot and setting. However, it leaves the reader slightly confused as to the meaning of the play.	Fair Displays a minimal understanding of the characters, plot and/or setting. Does not represent meaning of the play at all.	Poor Does not display an understanding of the characters, plot and/or setting. Little evidence that the play was read.
Captions & Thought/Speech Bubbles	Excellent Captions, quotations and thought/speech bubbles are related to the the play; connections to play are easy to understand.	Good Captions, quotations and thought/speech bubbles are related to the play; most connections to play are easy to understand.	Fair Captions, quotations and/or thought/speech bubbles are somewhat related to the play; connections are less obvious and hard to understand.	Poor Captions, quotations and/or thought/speech bubbles do not relate to the play; no demonstration of text comprehension; no connection to play.
Creativity	Excellent Project is creative, unique, and shows excellent originality and comprehension of play. Evidence that panels were well thought out.	Good Project is original; shows care and organization as well as vague comprehension of play.	Fair Project shows little originality; clearly confusion in comprehension of play.	Poor Project contains no originality, creativeness or comprehension; writing copied directly from text.
Artwork	Excellent Artwork is creative, attention to detail, captions and bubbles are easily defined. Follows story line. Sy	Good Artwork is complete but missing color/definition. Some pictures do not fit the story line.	Fair Artwork is done hastily, without thought, does not add to the story.	Poor No artwork