iRubric: Peer Review Rubric

No evidence of any contribution to the discussion. Fails to initiate the discussion. Fails to respond to other group member's comments. Simply<BR>
repeats the same point as other group members without providing reasons.

Some limited evidence of contribution to the discussion. Initiates some points in the discussion. Some evidence of having read and responded to other group member's comments.<BR>
Attempts to explain reasons for agreeing/disagreeing with other group members' comments.

Evidence of a reasonable contribution to the discussion. Initiates a number of points in the discussion. Evidence of having read and responded to other group member's comments.<BR>
Explains reasons for agreeing/disagreeing with other group members' comments with reference to case law, academic literature or legislation.

Good contribution to the discussion. Initiates many points in the discussion. Evidence of having read and responded to other group member's comments. Provides concise reasons for agreeing/disagreeing with other group members' comments.

Excellent contribution to the discussion. Initiates almost all points in the discussion. Clear evidence of having read and responded to other group member's comments.<BR>
Excellent explanation of reasons for agreeing/disagreeing with other group members' comments with reference to case law, academic literature or legislation.