2 pts
4 pts
6 pts
8 pts
10 pts
Cookies were appealing to the eye and representative of name. Evoked a desire to try.
Cookies are uniform in shape and individual (no running together). Cookies do not exhibit peaks or cracks.
Cookies exhibit sizing as noted on recipe and are even (depicting similar quantity of dough).
Cookies appear evenly dry in appearance and are not shiny or sticky.
Cookies are individually and collectively evenly browned, without dark edges and/or pale spots. There is no evidence of loose flour.
Cookie texture is as expected: Rolled/Refrigerator - crisp and tender. Drop - moist, soft, and tender. Bar - moist and tender.
Cookies have a delicate, sweet, well balanced flavor representative of type and flavor of cookie. Each cookie possesses adequate and even quantity of flavor enhancers (chocolate chips, raisins, etc.).