iRubric: Product Design Evaluation / Sketching rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Product Design Evaluation / Sketching

Rubric used in evaluating the sketching aspect of the design process

Rubric Code: KX5AAXA

By cooleycc

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: Engineering

Type: Project

Grade Levels: 9-12

Product Design Evaluation
	Exemplary 4 pts	Above Average 3 pts	Acceptable 2 pts	Poor 1 pts	Additional Comments (N/A)	Next Steps (N/A)
Defining the Problem	Exemplary A lengthy clear description where design specifications and constraints are offered. Research and supporting documentation shown an overwhelming need that the problem should be pursued by development.	Above Average A good statement and support/documentation is given to suggest the need to develop the product. Design specifications and constraints are also noted.	Acceptable A short description and explanation is offered to the problem without any support and specifications for development pursuits.	Poor Offers and unclear statement of the problem. There is no support, documentation, or need for development. Little or no work is evident.	Additional Comments	Next Steps
Conceptual Design and Sketching	Exemplary Multiple thumbnail drawings are offered (minimum of 5). Additionally, accurate orthographic and isometric views are drawn to proportion for communicating the design for review. Design specifications are clearly noted on the sketches.	Above Average More than two sketches are offered for a review. The sketches include design specifications and annotation for developing the design.	Acceptable At least two sketches are offered for a review. The sketches offer no design specifications or annotation	Poor Only one sketch is offered for a design review.	Additional Comments	Next Steps
Engineering Testing and Evaluation	Exemplary Many new ideas are generated as an outcome of brainstorming and research. Suggestions and details are given for design constraints of the product and for manufacturing.	Above Average Ideas generated are new and original as an outcome of brainstorming and research. Little suggestions are offered for the rest of the design process if any.	Acceptable Research is evident as an outcome of brainstorming. Ideas generated are a result of the brainstorming process and not original.	Poor Little research and brainstorming accomplished. Ideas generated are not original	Additional Comments	Next Steps
Total Section Points	Exemplary	Above Average	Acceptable	Poor	Additional Comments	Next Steps