iRubric: Part 1 Summary rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Part 1 Summary

Dante's Inferno Project. Contains 5 parts of the project both individual and group work is involved. This rubric covers part 1, the Summary which will be turned in individually. Each student will turn one in. Original Rubric by Sarah Moore Project ideas adapted from amphi.com

Rubric Code: VX4X277

By MissMoore

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: English

Type: Writing

Grade Levels: 9-12

Part 1 Summary Realm Examination
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 4 pts	Good 7 pts	Perfect 10 pts
Summary of Cantos Summarize the section of study Canto by Canto. Summaries must clearly explain the “crime and punishment” of the Circle of Hell examined. Explain the “sin” and fully describe the punishment and its appropriateness as it relates to the sin.	Poor There is no coherency or accuracy when summarizing the cantos. Summary lacks any organization, flow, or transition from one idea to the next. Summary is between 0 to 100 words long.	Fair There is little coherency in ideas. Transitions between ideas aren't smooth. The explanations of the cantos are inaccurate and lacking any connection between the sin and the punishment. Summary is between 100 to 300 words long.	Good Summary lacks flow from one idea to the next. Ideas are scattered and don't connect. The Sin and punishment are not explained clearly. Lacking connection between the crime and the punishment. Summary is between 300 to 450 words long.	Perfect Summary of the cantos are accurate and clearly summarize the crime and punishment of the circle of hell examined. The explanation of the sin is clear and the punishment as it relates to the sin is thoroughly explained. Thesis statement is strong. There is a flow and good transition from one idea to the next. The summary is in paragraph form. Summary is between 450-650 words long.
Characters B. Identify all residents. This is not just a list-explain who they are and their sin/connection to Dante’s world. Remember to include mythological creatures as well.	Poor No understanding of the characters is shown. There is no connection to Dante and no explanation or understanding of their sin or character.	Fair Character descriptions lack comprehension and accuracy. Format is incorrect.	Good All characters are not present in the report. Characters are lacking detail, connection to Dante, and/or their sin. Analysis of characters is slightly inaccurate. Format does not follow the bullet style format.	Perfect Each character from the cantos are explained in full detail. A complete explanation of who the character is, their connection to Dante, and their sin is clearly explained. The characters are outlined in a way that is easy to follow and understand. Characters are outlined in bullet format with a full description of each character in paragraph style format.
Relate to Modern World Relate the passage to the modern world. Include “modern” (post Dante) residents justifiably placed in the realm. Identify historical or fictional characters (think about the literature selections covered in literature classes) that Dante may have placed in each circle AND explain why.	Poor Student lacks any analysis of characters from their realm of hell as they relate to modern day characters. Format is incorrect. Explanations show no signs of comprehension of the assignment.	Fair There is very little evidence of connections between the characters in the realm of hell of those from the modern world. Explanations are inaccurate and incoherent. Format is inaccurate- not in paragraph/bullet format.	Good Student lacks slight connection between characters in their realm of hell and characters from the modern world. Explanations are slightly unclear or inaccurate.	Perfect Student shows full comprehension of Dante's inferno as it relates to the modern world. Student identifies historical or fictional characters that correlate to Dante's Inferno. Student clearly explains why these characters may be chosen by Dante to be in your chosen realm of hell. Clear and coherent explanation is given. Paragraph/Bullet format.
Grammar and Spelling Please make sure to proofread for accurate spelling and grammar.	Poor more than 10 spelling and grammatical errors. Paper shows evidence of no proofreading.	Fair 6-10 Spelling and grammatical errors found. Paper shows little evidence of proofreading.	Good 4-5 spelling or grammatical errors found. Paper lacks proofreading.	Perfect Perfect spelling and grammar. Paper has been proofread and shows no errors in grammar or spelling.
Format (Double spaced, Times New Roman 12 pt. font) APA Style Format Credible Sources Paragraph Style	Poor No formatting is apparent. No title page, no bibliography, no paragraph structure.	Fair Students shows very little evidence of APA Style formatting. Title page, summary, bibliography are inaccurate.	Good Paper demonstrates partial formatting in APA Style. Some formatting is inaccurate; i.e. title page, bibliography.	Perfect Paper is in APA style format with a title page. Proper bullets are used. 12 point font. Times New Roman. Paragraph style. Sources are credible and citations are accurate. Citations and references are accurate and bibliography listed on final page of paper in proper format.

Subjects:

English

Types:

Writing

Discuss this rubric