iRubric: Comparative Analysis Paper rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Comparative Analysis Paper

This paper will determine how you have mastered the art of comparative analysis. If you show that you have an above and beyond understanding of the topic then you will receive full credit.

Rubric Code: VX25734

By Teezus_BSB

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: English

Type: Writing

Grade Levels: 9-12

Essential Elements for Writing
	Poor 5 pts	Fair 10 pts	Good 15 pts	Excellent 20 pts
Grammar	Poor Too many grammatical errors.	Fair Many grammatical errors.	Good Few grammatical errors.	Excellent No grammatical errors.
Organization	Poor Ideas show no fluidity with one another. Ideas do not follow any set structure. Does not show any prior planning.	Fair Ideas are not fully aligned but they seem somewhat fluid. Shows little prior planning.	Good Ideas are structured in a way that makes it easy to understand. Shows prior planning.	Excellent Excellent fluidity of paper. Good sentence structure. Well thought out and shows prior planning.
Content	Poor Shows little knowledge of the main idea of the paper. Random thoughts.	Fair Shows a minor understanding of the main idea of the paper. Undeveloped Ideas	Good Shows a good understanding of the main idea of the paper. Developed Ideas	Excellent Shows a strong understanding of the main idea of the paper.
Passage Usage	Poor Uses no outside sources as evidence of paper's claims. Irrelevant details.	Fair Uses very little outside sources as evidence of paper's claims. Details sometimes relevant.	Good Uses a good amount of outside sources as evidence of paper's claims. Relevant details.	Excellent Uses many outside resources as evidence of paper's claims. Relevant details.
Language/Word Choice	Poor No challenge in vocabulary. Poor word usage. Tone inappropriate for audience.	Fair Tone was appropriate at times but not at other times. Few vocabulary challenges.	Good Some vocabulary challenges. Good tone.	Excellent Strong vocabulary language. Tone always appropriate.