iRubric: Sugar Cookie Rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Sugar Cookie Rubric

Students will be given a sugar cookie recipe and asked to divide the recipe in half. They must then complete the recipe from start to finish in 75 minutes with 25 minutes of freezer time, during which time students will complete a 46 question food-safety/menu items written exam.

Rubric Code: U2W588W

By perryculinary

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: Vocational

Type: Assessment

Grade Levels: 9-12, Undergraduate

Cookie Rubric
	Poor 5 Lack of effort, improper behavior or use of equipment, wandered out of assigned group, or didn't do assigned kitchen duties. 5 pts	Fair 10 Participated with only minimal effort, tendency to wander, minimal cleanup effort, skill level needs improvement. 10 pts	Good 15 Practiiced good teamwork skills, completed all personal, pre-prep, and pre skills, completed kitchen duties, shows professionalism, good attitude, shows creativity, practices good techniques. 15 pts	Excellent 20 Shows leadership skills within group and class, shows professionalism, mastered techniques, shows creativity, completes assigned jobs and kitchen duties. 20 pts
Texture	Poor 5 Poor- The cookie is over-cooked or under-cooked.	Fair 10 Fair-The cookie is fully cooked but only crisp or only chewy.	Good 15 Good-The cookie is crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside.	Excellent 20 Excellent-The cookie is crispy on the outside, is chewy on the inside, and includes moistness but is not greasy.
Appearance	Poor 5 Poor-The cookie is broken, burnt, or raw.	Fair 10 Fair-The cookie is golden brown and less than 2" in diameter.	Good 15 Good- The cookie is whole, golden brown, 2"-4" in diameter.	Excellent 20 Excellent- The cookie is whole, golden brown, 4" in diameter. It is thickest in the center and thinner on the edges, and presented on an aesthetically pleasing plate or napkin.
Taste	Poor 5 Poor- The cookie is stale, salty, or dry. It is tasteless with bland flavored dough.	Fair 10 Fair- The cookie is semi-fresh with a buttery flavor.	Good 15 Good- Delicious! - The cookie is fresh with a sweet, buttery flavor.	Excellent 20 Excellent- Heaven in your mouth! - The cookie is oven fresh with a sweet, rich, buttery flavor.
Smell	Poor 5 Poor-The cookie smells burnt or unpleasant, or has no smell at all.	Fair 10 Fair-The cookie has a buttery odor when held near the nose.	Good 15 Good-The cookie has a buttery odor when held at an arm's length.	Excellent 20 Excellent-The cookie has a rich, buttery smell from 6' away. The smell makes your mouth water and want a cookie.