iRubric: Deep Revision Assignment rubric

(draft) edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Deep Revision Assignment

For this assignment, students were asked to substantially revise an original essay’s content so that it was clearly and considerably improved, in addition to fixing any punctuation and grammar errors identified on the original. They were asked to complete a five-sentence critical reflection paragraph in which they explained their revision choices.

Rubric Code: GX27AA3

By kellyclasen

Draft

Public Rubric

Subject: English

Type: Writing

Grade Levels: Undergraduate

Deep Revision
	Poor Submission falls short of assignment expectations. 1 pts	Fair Submission exhibits a sincere attempt to fulfill most components of assignment. 2 pts	Excellent Submission meets or surpasses all elements of the Deep Revision assignment. 3 pts
Grammar and Punctuation	Poor Grammar and punctuation errors that were identified for the student on the first draft have not been addressed in the second draft.	Fair Most grammar and punctuation issues have been addressed.	Excellent The revised essay is virtually free of distracting grammar and punctuation errors.
Content and Organization	Poor The essay does not reflect an attempt to revise the essay for organization, idea development (length), or argument.	Fair The essay suggests some attention to revising for organization, idea development (length, or argument, but there is still room for improvement.	Excellent The essay reflects major improvements to the essay's organization, idea development, and/or argument due to the student's revisions.
Critical Reflection	Poor There is no critical reflection, or it does not suggest that the writer thought critically about the revision process.	Fair The critical reflection indicates a sincere attempt at self-assessment, even if it could be more developed.	Excellent The critical reflection is clear and thoughtful, demonstrates critical thinking, and is adequately developed.