iRubric: Value Composition in Vine Charcoal or Graphite rubric

Composition fills entire format. Unified and interesting composition
Composition meets all subject matter and Compositional requirements
Compositional requirements: cylindrical objects that intersect (minimum of 3 intersections) some objects appear to go back into the picture space. All objects have a clear sense of roundness/ volume illuminated from one light source

Composition fills entire format
Composition is Unified and interesting
Composition meets most of the subject matter and Compositional requirements
Most of the
Compositional requirements are met:
cylindrical objects that intersect (2- 3 intersections)
some objects appear to go back into the picture space. Most of the objects have a clear sense of roundness/ volume

Composition fills entire format
Composition is requires some tweaking to strengthen unity or variety
At least half of the
Compositional requirements are met: Some objects appear to go back into the picture space. Some (at least half of) objects have a clear sense of roundness/ volume

No clear thought to composition- appears to be a sketch or study
Composition does NOT fill the entire format
Compositional requirements: Some objects appear to go back into the picture space

Great pride and care has been taken by the artist to present a neat, unmarred, and flat final composition ready for mounting.

Composition shows some lack of care- slightly creased or smudged.

Composition shows greater lack of care- multiple creases or crumpled, smudges, etc.

Composition shows signs of neglect that demonstrate the artist's lack of pride in the work.