Does not meet the standard
(N/A)
Meets little or minimal criteria.
Meets some criteria, is passable.
Meets most criteria.
Meets or exceeds all criteria. An excellent example.
Attractive in appearance, neatly presented, has mass appeal.
Cookies are uniform in size and appearance.
Used proper measuring techniques, demonstrated understanding of sequences while following recipe instructions, used the right tools for the task, etc.
Cookie has a distinct and pleasing flavor that would appeal to many.
Cookie is chewy/crispy/soft with a moist center. Good mouth feel.
There is a balance of cookie flavor and texture that is pleasing and flavors blend together well.
Managed time properly and set timer for proper cookie doness. Station is organized, used the right tools for the task, clean as you work, etc.
Station cleaned/sanitized while working, proper use of sani/soap buckets, no cross-contamination, etc.