iRubric: Gradual Abstraction rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Gradual Abstraction

Identity Package

Rubric Code: R98B95

By reecea

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: Arts and Design

Type: Project

Grade Levels: 9-12

Basic requirements 40 % Did student meet the minimum expecations for the project?
	Dreadful The quality of work is far below the minimum standard. 0 pts	Poor The quality of the work is slightly below the minimum acceptable standard. 6 pts	Acceptable The quality of the work is average; acceptable, but unimpressive. 8 pts	Exceeds Expectations The quality of the work produced exceeds the average. 9 pts	Outstanding The quality of the work far exceeds the average. Very impressive. 10 pts
3-up 10 pts	Dreadful Student failed to submit the file correctly.	Poor Student submitted a file, but did so incorrectly.	Acceptable N/A	Exceeds Expectations Student submited the file correctly, except for the name.	Outstanding Student submited the file correctly.
Photorealistic 10 pts	Dreadful Student failed to submit the file correctly.	Poor Student submitted a file, but did so incorrectly.	Acceptable N/A	Exceeds Expectations Student submited the file correctly, except for the name.	Outstanding Student submited the file correctly.
Clipart 10 pts	Dreadful Student failed to submit the file correctly.	Poor Student submitted a file, but did so incorrectly.	Acceptable N/A	Exceeds Expectations Student submited the file correctly, except for the name.	Outstanding Student submited the file correctly.
Icon 10 pts	Dreadful Student failed to submit the file correctly.	Poor Student submitted a file, but did so incorrectly.	Acceptable N/A	Exceeds Expectations Student submited the file correctly, except for the name.	Outstanding Student submited the file correctly.
Originality 10 % How much thought went into the design's concept, regardless of execution?
	Dreadful The quality of work is far below the minimum standard. 0 pts	Poor The quality of the work is below the minimum acceptable standard. 6 pts	Acceptable The quality of the work is average; acceptable, but unimpressive. 8 pts	Exceeds Expectations The quality of the work produced exceeds the average. 9 pts	Outstanding The quality of the work far exceeds the average. Very impressive. 10 pts
Overall 10 pts Is the design's concept new and modern or was it derived from a commonly seen idea. Sketches and roughs provide evidence of this.	Dreadful The concept is unclear.	Poor The concept is weak. Often seen and duplicated.	Acceptable The concept meets minimum standards. Unoriginal, clearly derived from an often seen design.	Exceeds Expectations The concept is modern. Somewhat original, but derived from another design.	Outstanding The concept is progressive. Never before seen.
Composition 20 % How well was the design executed from an aesthetic aspect?
	Dreadful The quality of work is far below the minimum standard. 0 pts	Poor The quality of the work is below the minimum acceptable standard. 6 pts	Acceptable The quality of the work is average; acceptable, but unimpressive. 8 pts	Exceeds Expectations The quality of the work produced exceeds the average. 9 pts	Outstanding The quality of the work far exceeds the average. Very impressive. 10 pts
Overall Design 5 pts How well do the designs work? Is communication clear? Is it pleasing to the eye?	Dreadful The design is poor. The message is confusing due to the composition. It is unpleasant to view.	Poor The design is unclear and the message is hindered by the composition. It is uninteresting to look at.	Acceptable The message is clear but is unsupported by the design. The design is not unpleasant but is uninteresting.	Exceeds Expectations The message is clear and supported by the composition. The design is pleasing to view.	Outstanding The design is of the highest quality. The message is enhanced by the composition. The design is pleasing to view.
Photorealism 5 pts	Dreadful The painting does not resemble a photograph of the object.	Poor The painting somewhat resembles a photograph of the object. Serious problems with colors, shading, and form.	Acceptable The painting resembles a photograph of the object. Multiple problems with colors, shading, and form.	Exceeds Expectations The painting is nearly indistinguishable from a photograph at first glance. Only minor errors present in color, shading, or form.	Outstanding The painting is nearly indistinguishable from a photograph of the object even under close study. Only very insignicant errors present.
Clipart 5 pts	Dreadful The illustration does not communicate the original form of the object. There are serious issues with form and color.	Poor The illustration somewhat communicates the original form of the object. There are some issues with form and color.	Acceptable The illustration clearly communicates the original form of the object. There are many minor issues with form and color.	Exceeds Expectations The illustration clearly communicates the original form of the object. There are a few minor issues with form or color.	Outstanding The illustration clearly communicates the original form of the object. There are no notable issues with form or color.
Icon 5 pts	Dreadful The illustration does not communicate the original form of the object.	Poor The illustration communicates the original form of the object but has serious issues.	Acceptable The illustration communicates the original form of the object but has some issues.	Exceeds Expectations The illustration communicates the original form of the object but has a few minor issues.	Outstanding The illustration communicates the original form of the object and has no notable issues.
Craftsmanship 30 % How well was the design executed from a technical aspect?
	Dreadful The quality of work is far below the minimum standard. 0 pts	Poor The quality of the work is below the minimum acceptable standard. 6 pts	Acceptable The quality of the work is average; acceptable, but unimpressive. 8 pts	Exceeds Expectations The quality of the work produced exceeds the average. 9 pts	Outstanding The quality of the work far exceeds the average. Very impressive. 10 pts
Overall Quality 10 pts How well was the design executed?	Dreadful The design was poorly executed. Sloppy work throughout.	Poor The design needed more work. Some problems could have been corrected with moderate effort.	Acceptable The design demonstrated quality work with minimal errors. Some problems could have been corrected with only minimal effort.	Exceeds Expectations The design demonstrated high quality work.	Outstanding The design demonstrated near professional level workmanship.
Technical Quality 10 pts How well were the tools used?	Dreadful The design demonstrates a serious lack of understanding of the basic tools.	Poor The design demonstrates a lack of understanding of the tools. More practice with the basic tools is warranted.	Acceptable The design demonstrates a basic understanding of the tools. Using more advanced techniques would have improved the design.	Exceeds Expectations The design demonstrates an advanced understanding of the basic tools. Student has experimented/attempted advanced techniques.	Outstanding The design demonstrates an advanced understanding of the tools . Advanced techniques were successfully used in new ways and pushed the envelope.
Attention to Detail 10 pts	Dreadful The design has many errors. Sloppy work, no attention to detail.	Poor The design has some serious mistakes that should have been corrected.	Acceptable The design has some minor mistakes. No attempt was made at correcting the mistakes.	Exceeds Expectations The design has some minor mistakes. A visible attempt was made to correct the mistakes , but failed.	Outstanding The design has no detectable mistakes. Great care was taken with the small details.

Subjects:

Arts and Design

Types:

Project

Discuss this rubric