iRubric: POE Engineering Design Challenge rubric

(draft) edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

POE Engineering Design Challenge

Your team has been given a design challenge. Use the design process to create, build, test and present your project.

Rubric Code: FX5784X

By fooseballer

Draft

Public Rubric

Subject: Engineering

Type: Project

Grade Levels: 9-12

Engineering Design Challenge
	Excellent 4 pts	Good 3 pts	Fair 2 pts	Poor 1 pts
Problem	Excellent The problem is clearly stated and all constraints are clearly listed.	Good The problem and constraints can be found but are not clearly stated at the beginning	Fair Either the problem or the constraints are missing	Poor Both the problem and constraints are absent
Brainstorming	Excellent Clear examples of brainstorming and research can be found. At least 10 different ideas can be shown before work started.	Good Brainstorming and research are at least present. At least 5 ideas can be clearly shown before work started	Fair Brainstorming or research is limited. Less that 5 ideas are present before work started.	Poor Brainstorming and research can not be clearly shown.
Design Prototype	Excellent A clear 3-d model can be shown and a flow chart showing desired programming is present. Final product is very close to original design.	Good A drawing is present but is not isometric or 3-d. Flowchart is present but does not follow a clear path. Final product resembles drawing.	Fair Either the initial drawing or the flowchart is not clear or does not resemble final product.	Poor Drawing or flowchart is missing. Final product has no resemblance to original design.
Build Prototype	Excellent Documentation of build process is present throughout the project. Changes in design are thoroughly noted. Lean process is addressed and followed	Good Documentation of build process is incomplete but present. Changes in design are noted but incomplete. Lean process is followed inconsistently	Fair Documentation of build process is weak but present. Changes in design process are not clearly noted. Lean process is followed weakly.	Poor Build process is not documented. Changes in design are not notated. Lean process is not followed.
Test Prototype	Excellent There is collected data showing that the product works and meets all constraints. If redesign is necessary it is clearly notated and followed	Good Tests to show that the product works have been run but not clearly detailed. If redesign is necessary, it has not been clearly notated.	Fair There is limited evidence of product testing. Redesigns have happened without documentation.	Poor There is no clear examples of product testing or redesign.
Present Final Product	Excellent Final product is presented in working order. The presentation clearly demonstrates the product and the process. All team members play a part in the process.	Good Final product is presented in semi-working condition. The presentation addresses the product and the process. All members do not play key roles in presentation.	Fair Final product is presented but does not work. The presentation weakly addresses either the product or the process. Significant lack of presentation from one or more team members	Poor Product is not presented or has severe fatal flaws. Presentation is missing product and process demonstration. One person presents whole presentation.

Subjects:

Engineering

Types:

Project

Discuss this rubric