iRubric: Design Brief Rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...

Design Brief Rubric

If you could invent something to make your life easier, what would it be? Develop a design proposal for a product that would make your life easier. The design proposal should include sketches of your idea, the essential functions and who your product serves. Once your initial idea has been developed, solicit feedback from your peers to revise and update the final design proposal.

Rubric Code: A8459X

By tutortutor

Ready to use

Public Rubric

Subject: Computers

Type: Project

Grade Levels: 9-12

Design Brief Proposal Rubric
	Below Average 0 pts	Average 1 pts	Above Average 2 pts	Good 3 pts	Excellent 4 pts
Title Page/Introduction	Below Average There is no title page and introduction to design team.	Average The title page and introduction to design team includes 1 of the component	Above Average The title page and introduction to design team includes all but 2 of the components, including a three-dimensional sketch/image of the invention.	Good The title page and introduction to design team includes all but one of the components including a three-dimensional sketch/image of the invention.	Excellent The title page and introduction to design team includes all components, including a three-dimensional sketch/image of the invention.
Purpose of Invention Enter description	Below Average There is no clear purpose or background or any mention of the problem the invention is trying to solve.	Average	Above Average The purpose includes brief background information related to the invention and does not include the problem the invention is trying to solve.	Good The purpose of the invention includes some background information related to the invention and does include the the problem the invention is trying to solve.	Excellent The purpose of the invention includes significant background information related to the invention and the problem the invention is trying to solve.
Overview of Procedure Enter description	Below Average There is no procedure and does not show how research and development of a product is prepared in the marketplace.	Average	Above Average The overview of procedure show some steps but does not show how research and development of a product to prepare it for the marketplace.	Good The overview of procedure reflects the steps the company would use to conduct research and development of a product to prepare it for marketplace.	Excellent The overview of procedure accurately reflects the steps a company would use to conduct research and development of a product to prepare it for marketplace.
Timeline Timeline	Below Average There is no timeline or steps of the product.	Average	Above Average The steps are not clearly shown from the overview and does not include realistic deadlines.	Good The timeline includes some steps from the overview but does not include realistic deadlines.	Excellent The timeline, presented in a clear manner, includes all steps from the overview, with realistic deadlines.
Budget	Below Average There is no budget.	Average The budget accurately shows costs only associated with the invention.	Above Average The budget accurately shows costs only associated with the invention and testing the invention.	Good The budge accurately shows costs associated with the invention testing the invention but no mention of paying employees for the development of the invention.	Excellent The budget accurately reflects costs associated with creating the invention, testing the invention, and paying employees for the development of the invention.
Summary	Below Average There is no summary.	Average	Above Average Summary is no longer than a paragraph and represents some of the information presented in the design proposal.	Good Summary is no longer than a paragraph and represents most of the information presented in the design proposal.	Excellent Summary is no longer than one paragraph and concisely represents all of the information presented in the design proposal.
Developing a Survey	Below Average The product survey was not designed to collect usable feedback to improve the product.	Average	Above Average The product survey featured some questions without a clear purpose. The reviewer provided few (1-2) opportunities to comment on the product and provide feedback. There was no usable data-hard to read	Good The product survey featured well designed questions with a specific purpose. The reviewer provided some opportunities to comment on the product and provide feedback. Usable data was collected.	Excellent The product survey featured well designed questions, with a specific purpose. The reviewer had clear opportunities to comment on the product and provide feedback. Usable data was collected.
Analyzing Feedback	Below Average There was no feedback.	Average The student incorporated usable data but did not show recommendations or a plan to refine the product.	Above Average The student incorporated usable data into the redesign of the product. The student was able to anticipate recommendations and had a plan to refine the product.	Good	Excellent The student used the data as a reflection on the products evolution. Responses were accurate with insight in the products redesign. The student used feedback to improve the product and was able to anticipate the products evolution.
Product Development	Below Average There was no product development	Average The design proposal was detailed but did not include the essential functions of the product and did not include any marketing information. Comments were written in run-on sentences. The product sketch was not drawn and did not show both product function and purpose behind the products. The design proposal incorporated little feedback to improve the product while citing sources. There were 6-more grammatical/spelling mistakes.	Above Average	Good The design proposal was detailed and included the essential functions of the product but did not include any marketing information. Comments were written in run-on sentences. The product sketch was annotated and showed both product function and purpose behind the products. The design proposal incorporated feedback to improve the product while citing sources. There were 3-5 grammatical/spelling mistakes.	Excellent The design proposal was detailed and included the essential functions of the product as well as all of the necessary marketing information. Comments were in complete sentences. The product sketch was annotated and showed both product function and purpose behind the products design. The design proposal incorporated feedback to improve the product while citing sources. There were no grammatical or spelling mistakes or contained 2-4 grammatical/spelling mistakes.

Subjects:

Computers

Types:

Project

Discuss this rubric