iRubric: Rubric for student judges of debates

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Rubric for student judges of debates Debate Student judges will use this rubric to help them to decide which team will win the debate. Rubric Code: N94494 By kvanderdrift22 Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: (General) Type: Project Grade Levels: 9-12

Judge's Rubric
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 2 pts	Good 3 pts	Excellent 4 pts
Preparation	Poor no evidence of any reading or research	Fair evidence of some reading or research, if incomplete or scattered	Good clear evidence of thorough reading and research	Excellent clear evidence of thorough reading and research, including notes or bookmarks
Comprehension	Poor no understanding of the topic and plan	Fair partial understanding of the topic and plan	Good complete but superficial understanding of the topic and plan	Excellent thorough and sophisticated understanding of the topic and plan
Persuasiveness	Poor irrelevant, counterproductive, or nonexistent contributions to team's argument	Fair some helpful contributions to team's argument	Good consistently helpful contributions to team's argument	Excellent sophisticated argumentation contributing substantially to team's argument
Performance	Poor no clear communication, no evidence of listening	Fair somewhat clear communication, some evidence of listening	Good mostly clear communication, evidence of consistent listening	Excellent consistently clear communication, evidence of consistent and thoughtful listening
Cooperation	Poor no collaboration with peers	Fair some collaboration with peers	Good consistent collaboration with peers	Excellent consistent collaboration with peers effectively strengthening team's argument