iRubric: Jr. Values & Philosophy paper rubric

Reflection not thoughtfully applied to one's life. Few or no insights shown. Focused on others rather than self. may resemble a lecture more than a personal reflection. May have two or more issues with unity, coherence, or organization. May not have addressed/answered more than two questions on handout. Lacks detail and/or is undeveloped. Does not meet minimum requirements.
Any plagiarism = Zero points earned & a written referral.

0 - 51 points

Reflection could be more thoughtfully applied to one's life. Few insights shown. At times too much focus on others rather than self or resembles a lecture more than a reflection. May not have answered one or two questions on handout provided. May lack detail or be undeveloped at times. May have one or two issues with unity, coherence, or organization.


52 - 58 points

A thoughtful/insightful personal reflection that references self. Paper may have one or two issues with using good unity, coherence and organization. Essay answers all of the questions on provided handout, but may lack detail or be undeveloped at times. The reflection may focus on others instead of self or resemble a lecture in one area. Meets length requirements.
59 - 65 points

A thoughtful/insightful personal reflection focused on self using good unity, coherence and organization. Essay completely and thoroughly answers questions on provided handout. The reflection does not resemble a lecture in any way. Reflection is the required length.




66 - 70 points

Paper has five or more issues with grammar, usage and/or mechanics, and/or student uses the second person pronoun three or more times.

(one point deducted for each error after six in both categories combined)
0 - 10 points

Paper has three to four issues with grammar, usage and/or mechanics, and/or student uses the second person pronoun once or twice.





11 - 12 points

Paper has one or two issues with grammar, usage and/or mechanics. Student refrains from using the second person pronoun.





13 - 14 points

Paper is free of any grammatical, usage, and mechanical issues. Student refrains from using the second person pronoun.





15 points