iRubric: Proposal Argument Rubric

Description of the problem is clear, concise, and easy to understand

Solution is well-stated, manageable, appropriate, and comprehensive.

Description of the problem is clear and generally easy to understand with a few exceptions.

There is a logical and thoughtful plan for manageable execution of the solution/

The description of the problem is adequate though the need for greater clarity is apparent. Description may not explain problem and/or solution concisely or with a clear general picture of proposed activities.

Processes and procedures for executing the solution appear manageable, but there is some uncertainty.

Description of the problem is not clear.

Processes and procedures outlined are unclear, do not follow from solution objectives, and/or do not seem entirely manageable. Processes and procedures are either omitted, only vaguely stated, unmanageable, or are inappropriate for the solution proposed.

Either the description of the problem and/or solution is missing.

All requirements met and exceeded

All requirements met.

Most requirements met.

Some requirements met.

No clear evidence of requirements being met.

No MLA mistakes

1-2 minor mistakes

3-4 or more common minor mistakes

5 Uncommon mistakes or one major mistake

No evidence of MLA format or no works cited.