- Username
- Password
forgot?

iRubric: Panel Discussion Rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Panel Discussion Rubric Rubric Code: S95995 By BBrody Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Political Science Type: Presentation Grade Levels: Undergraduate

Panel Discussion Enter rubric description
	Fair (N/A)	Good (N/A)	Excellent (N/A)
Opening Statement 30 points maximum	Fair 0-19 Opening statement lacked in substance. Opening statement lacked in clarity. Opening statement needed significant increase in analytical rigor.	Good 20-24 Good opening statement. Some strong arguments presented. Needed more organization. Needed a higher level of analysis. Needed more substance.	Excellent 25-30 Strong opening statement. Topical and substantive arguments. Well organized and presented arguments. High level of analytical rigor.
Clarity 10 points Maximum	Fair 0-5 Arguments lacked clarity. Many points were inconsistent. Did not effectively clarify points/arguments during the discussion.	Good 6-7 Could have better clarified your arguments for the group. Some arguments were not consistent. Good clarification of your points during the discussion.	Excellent 8-10 Excellent job in this area. Clear and intelligible arguments. Excellent clarification of your points within the discussion.
Argumentation/Style 10 points maximum	Fair 0-5 Need more engagement with the larger discussion. Need work in this area.	Good 6-7 Good job in this area. Argumentation could have been more sophisticated. Good engagement with the larger discussion.	Excellent 8-10 Excellent job in this area. Persuasive argumentation. Excellent engagement with the larger discussion.
Position Paper 50 points maximum	Fair 0-39 The paper lacked in substance. The paper lacked in clarity. The paper lacked in organization.	Good 40-49 Paper could have been improved in terms of substance. Paper could have been improved in terms of clarity. Paper could have been improved in terms of organization.	Excellent 45-50 Clear substantive and organized paper.