iRubric: Class debate rubric

(draft) edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Class debate Students will debate "Mrs. Maloney would be better off if she didn't kill Mr. Maloney" Rubric Code: FX9X48B By ericcblondin Draft Public Rubric Subject: Humanities Type: Presentation Grade Levels: 9-12

National Anthem Debate
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 3 pts	Good 4 pts	Enter Title 5 pts
Opening: Proposition and Position	Poor Background Omitted Claims - none previewed Position not stated	Fair Background unrelated One Claim previewed Position ambiguous	Good Background sufficient Two claims previewed Position clear	Enter Title Background comprehensive Three claims previewed Position clearly stated
Claims 1, 2, 3	Poor Claims were illogical, unfocused, or dogmatic	Fair Few claims were logical clear and concise	Good Most claims were logical, clear and concise	Enter Title All claims were logical clear and concise
Refutation	Poor Did not identify any opposing arguments AND did not make any claims	Fair Did not identify at least one opposing claim BUT made a new argujment that supported their position	Good Clearly identified at least one opposing argument BUT was unable to effectively prove it to be inaccurate	Enter Title Clearly identified at least one opposing argument AND proved it to be inaccurte
Open Minute	Poor Did not particiapte	Fair Used time unsuccessfully	Good n/a	Enter Title Used time successfully
Communication	Poor Failed to maintain the audiences attention	Fair Maintained the audiences attention throughout some of the debate	Good Maintained the audiences attention throughout most of the debate	Enter Title Maintained the audiences attention throughout all of the debate