The proposal fails to meet expectations in the category named.
4 pts
The proposal meets all guidelines and expectations in the category named.
12 pts
The proposal exceeds expectations and guidelines in the category named.
15 pts
Problem, theoretical framework, and hypotheses are stated clearly.
Significance of problem is stated.
Assumptions and limitations are clearly stated.
Important terms are defined conceptually and operationally.
Coverage of the literature is adequate.
Literature review is well organized.
Studies are critically examined.
Source(s) of important fmdings is (are) noted.
Relationship of the problem to previous research is made clear.
The research design is described fully.
Research design is free of specific weaknesses.
Population and sample are described.
Sampling methods, data gathering methods, and procedures are appropriate.
Data gathering methods or procedures are described and used correctly.
Data gathering instruments are valid and reliable or implications of invalidity or unreliability are discussed.