iRubric: Debate Recording/Podcast rubric

establishes the significance of a claim or proposal;
distinguishes the claim from alternate or opposing claims;
skillfully supports claim(s) with logical reasoning and effective and relevant evidence
facts, definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples that are relevant, or and sufficient; demonstrates understanding of information as the writer examines the topic with in-depth, original ideas

establishes the significance of a claim; identifies the opposing claims; supports claim(s) with logical reasoning and effective and/or relevant evidence

attempts to establish the significance of a claim; mentions the opposing claims
skillfully supports claim; includes some reasoning evidence

claim presented; may not have counter claims; limited evidence

All of the major issues about the human right are presented thoughtfully in the debate

The debate presents some of the important issues about the topic.

The author did not address major issues associated with the topic.

None of the issues were addressed or not in a clear way.