- Username
- Password
forgot?

iRubric: Peer Writing Evaluation rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Peer Writing Evaluation Peer Writing Evaluation Students use this rubric to provide honest and appropriate feedback to shared work from a peer. Rubric Code: TXX866A By emdunleavy Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: (General) Type: Writing Grade Levels: 6-8

Peer Feedback Rubric
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 2 pts	Good 3 pts	Excellent 4 pts
Organization	Poor Very difficult to follow and/or find a main idea, point, theme, because the writing has no organization. It seems almost to "babble."	Fair There is an attempt at organizing the written thoughts, but the written points wander.	Good There is some organization making the piece easy to follow, but there are occasional written statements that do not seem to fit in their section.	Excellent The piece is very well organized with strong headings and details appropriate to those headings.
On Topic	Poor The piece seems to wander to whatever thought the writer had at the moment, rather than focused on any particular topic.	Fair Seems to have a main idea, point, or theme, but contains a lot of off topic sentences that make it hard to follow.	Good Main idea, point, or topic is clear and easy to follow, but contains some "distracting" off topic comments.	Excellent Main idea, point, or topic is very clear. All details pertain in some way to that main idea, point, or topic.
Interesting/Appropriate Detail	Poor Piece does not contain any details, or contains details that are boring or significantly inappropriate.	Fair There is an attempt at including details, but they are off topic or inappropriate to some degree.	Good Piece contains some interesting details but also contains some that are boring. None are off topic or inappropriate, though.	Excellent Piece contains interesting details on topic. These details engage the reader.
Grammar/Punctuation (Final ONLY)	Poor No attempt at correct grammar, punctuation, capitalization.	Fair Some attempt at correct grammar, punctuation, and capitalization, but I found many errors.	Good A good attempt at correct grammar, punctuation, and capitalization, but I found several errors.	Excellent Very good grammar, puntuation, and capitalization. I found few or no errors.
Flow	Poor This piece is hard to follow.	Fair I can follow the writer's ideas, but it is boring or rough.	Good Though there are some boring or rough places, the piece flows pretty well and is not boring.	Excellent This piece flows very well. It was easy to read and interesting, and I wanted to keep reading it all the way through.