- Username
- Password
forgot?

iRubric: APPE Journal Club rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
APPE Journal Club APPE Journal Club Rubric Code: LXW5998 By aswilson323 Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Pharmacy Type: Assessment Grade Levels: Graduate

Outcome/Performance Criteria 90 %
	Exceeds Expectations Complete, concise, and well organized presentation of material. No prompting required to elaborate on material. 5 pts	At/Above Expectations Well organized, partial but accurate information. Requires little prompting. 4 pts	Meets Expectations Organization needs work, limited amount of pertinent information provided or information inaccurate. Requires some prompting 3 pts	Partially Meets Expectation Poorly organized, missing and/or inaccurate information. Requires significant prompting / leading for information 2 pts	Does Not Meet Expectation Not addressed, grossly incomplete and/or inaccurate. Requires preceptor or other students to provide all information 1 pts
Outcome/Performance Criteria 40 % Communication Skills
Time limit 1 pts Presentation or paper is within allotted time or length (20 minutes)	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Format 1 pts Completely follows the accepted oral or written format	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Clarity 1 pts Speaks or writes clearly without errors in pronunciation, spelling, and/or grammar	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Delivery 1 pts Speaks with confidence, eye contact, and interacts with the audience OR writes with engaging style	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Language 1 pts Speaks or writes in language appropriate for the target audience	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Follow Up 1 pts Able to answer all questions accurately and within allotted time	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Outcome/Performance Criteria 50 % Biomedical Literature
Background 1 pts Provides audience with pertinent background information about topicdiscussed in journal article (epidemiology, risk factors, etc.)	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Previous Trials 1 pts Provides quick overview of other studies available including comparision of study populations, methodology, areas for improvement relative to study presenting	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Brief Summary 1 pts Brief summary (overview) of journal article before performing analysis (citation, funding, impact of journal, peer reviewed, hypothesis/null hypothesis, study design, endpoints etc)	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Study Population 1 pts Characteristics of study population presented (inclusion,exclusion, ITT), explained potential influence of excluded population on results	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Interventions 1 pts Summarizes and critiques interventions and methods (Logical? Sufficient detail? Consistent with current practice? Based on standard methods or published/validated scales/measures?	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Results/Statistics 1 pts Summarizes and critiques relevant results and discusses statistical and clinical significance (baseline characteristics? External validity? Patient withdrawal? ITT, per-protocol, or other analysis?)	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Author's Conclusions 1 pts Stated and assessed if valid based on study objectives and results.	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Critique 1 pts Strengths, limitations, bias presented	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Clinical Significance (Generalizabi 1 pts Articulates whether statistical significance (or lack thereof) correlates with clinical significance and how results can be applied to practice	Exceeds Expectations	At/Above Expectations	Meets Expectations	Partially Meets Expectation	Does Not Meet Expectation
Referencing 10 %
	Exceeds Expectations Complete, concise, and well organized presentation of material. No prompting required to elaborate on material. 5 pts	N/A (N/A)	N/A (N/A)	N/A (N/A)	Does Not Meet Expectation Not addressed, grossly incomplete and/or inaccurate. Reuires preceptor or other students to provide all information 0 pts
References 1 pts Follows referencing and citation format all of the time	Exceeds Expectations	N/A	N/A	N/A	Does Not Meet Expectation

Subjects:

Pharmacy

Types:

Assessment

Discuss this rubric